Skip to main content

Homelessness Programs Need a New Perspective

November 16 2026
Written by Tim Campbell.

iAUDIt! - Some Civil War historians have described Ulysses S. Grant’s approach to strategy and tactics by citing how he used battlefield maps.  Once his staff laid out a map showing troop dispositions, he would walk around the table and look at the situation from the Confederate point of view.  By changing his perspective, he gained insight into the strengths and weaknesses of his own lines as well as the enemy’s.  Unlike more tradition-bound generals on both sides, Grant was willing to change his strategy as real conditions changed. Perhaps his greatest strength as a general was that he was willing to see things as they were instead of as he wanted them to be. When he made a mistake (as he did with the disastrous attack at Cold Harbor in 1864), he accepted his error and adjusted his strategy. His promotion to general in chief of all Union forces marked a true turning point in the war.

When it comes to homelessness programs, Los Angeles may be on the cusp of a turning point. Mayor-elect Nithya Raman has promised a new approach, based on her claims of reducing street homelessness by 47 percent in her Council district, (more on that later).  Our new City Attorney, Marissa Roy, ran on implementing strong tenant protections aimed at preventing evictions.  County Supervisor Lindsey Horvath, who was once LAHSA’s Board Chair, recently announced she will run for the newly created position of County CEO, who will oversee the County’s new Homelessness and Housing Department.  LAHSA itself is beginning its death spiral, having lost federal and county funding and been stripped of its Continuum of Care functions, including the annual Point in Time count.  What we don’t know is how the turning point will play out. Are we seeing the beginning of a new paradigm, or are we just rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic, making superficial changes with no serious attempt to reform homelessness programs? Sadly, all indicators point to the latter.

First, let’s consider Councilmember Raman’s claim to have reduced street homelessness by 47 percent.  There are two important points in her statements we need to consider. First, the reduction was in “street homelessness”. That is different than actually reducing homelessness itself. A person moved from the street to a shelter is still considered homeless, and still requires public assistance.  They may be better off in a shelter, (although the shelter system is grossly mismanaged), but they are still homeless.  Second, although street homelessness in Raman’s district may have decreased, LA’s overall homelessness numbers increased by 3.4 percent, per LAHSA’s 2026 PIT count. It would be more accurate to say that homelessness decreased in some areas but increased in others, and it is almost impossible to attribute a decrease to a specific approach.  Homelessness in Councilmember Park’s district also decreased, and she uses a much different approach than Raman.  Park heavily relies on the city’s anti-camping ordinance, LAMC 41.18 to encourage urban campers to move into shelters.  Raman uses repetitive outreach to get people to accept shelter.  While there is no single right approach, Raman cannot claim hers is any better than Park’s, or anyone else’s, and the supposed reduction in her district could have merely been an artifact of the transient nature of the unhoused population.

Based on her statements after the election, Councilmember Raman will depend on time-limited subsidies to reduce citywide homelessness. As the name implies, time-limited subsidy (TLS) programs move homeless people into apartments and pay all or part of the rent for up to two years.  Theoretically, during this two-year period, clients receive support services such as job counseling or mental health therapy, so they can become responsible for their own housing.  But we know services are haphazard at best, as described in a 2024 All Aspect Report column. Clients, many of whom have addiction and/or mental health problems, often receive sporadic, if any, services, resulting in some returning to the streets.

TLS programs themselves have suffered from the same mismanagement that has plagued homelessness interventions for years.  A December 2023 LAist article describes how HOPICS, a large nonprofit with numerous government contracts, received $140 million for rapid rehousing programs, and then mismanaged its subcontractors to the point hundreds of clients were forced out of their apartments for nonpayment of rent.  In the broader context of how poorly local governments manage homelessness programs, the HOPICS debacle is just an example of how billions in funding have been poured into programs with almost no oversight.

In my last column, I mentioned a recent court-ordered report from audit firm Nardello & Co.  Taking a closer look at the report, we can see how unserious local officials have taken their duty to oversee homelessness programs.  Pages 10 and 11 summarized the report’s findings, describing, among other things:

  • Providers are allowed to define their own descriptions of key performance indicators like clients “served” and inconsistent reporting practices for “participant activity, occupancy, referrals, and engagement”.  In other words, city, county, and LAHSA departments have not imposed standardized reporting requirements on providers, essentially abdicating their managerial role by allowing organizations to self-define program performance, and therefore payments for services which may or may not have been provided.
  • As reported in other reviews and by the news media, LAHSA cannot assure the numbers it reports for people served are not duplicated.  As clients move from outreach to shelters to housing, they may be counted as “unique” each time.  Therefore, when agencies like the Mayor’s office claim 27,000 people have been sheltered or housed, what they are really saying is that certain types of processes may have been performed 27,000 times on an unknown but potentially much smaller population of unhoused people.
  • Service reporting is decentralized among city and county departments with no overarching process for those departments to reconcile the data.  For example, the City’s Chief Administrative Officer’s staff rely on self-reported information from service providers, and they do not verify the data’s accuracy.  Other programs rely on the Homelessness Management Information System (HMIS), which has never fully captured provider activity.  A 2023 report from the United Way and RAND found that only about 48 percent of providers use the HMIS, while most rely on some kind of Excel spreadsheets to track client services.  This exacerbates the problem of ensuring program numbers reflect services provided to unique individuals.  It would be nearly impossible to find duplicated individuals across a broad range of different reports and datasets.

Perhaps the most important lesson to take from Nardello’s report is that it is just the most recent negative review in a series stretching back almost 20 years.  This is the system that Mayor-elect Raman and potential County CEO Horvath have perpetuated and defended.  (Let’s forget Raman co-authored a letter to the Board of Supervisors opposing the County defunding LAHSA, and Horvath chaired LAHSA’s Board when the County Auditor issued its devastating report on the Authority’s financial practices in November 2024, exclaiming “LAHSA is us”!. ). It is very unlikely we will see substantive reform just because those in power change offices.  As I wrote in July 2025, the Board of Supervisors selected Sarah Mahin, a former LAHSA senior manager, to head the new County Department of Homeless Services and Housing. Ms. Mahin was LAHSA’s Director of Policy and Systems from 2016 until early 2019.  As I described in my column, these were years when LAHSA’s budget ballooned even as homelessness increased.  There is scant hope the County’s new department will move away from unproductive programs when its executive is steeped in the culture of continuous failure that has defined LAHSA’s operations for years.

In 1864, Ulysses Grant brought real change to the Union’s strategy. As Civil War historian Bruce Catton wrote of generals who had to adapt to Grant’s perspective, men who talked about great victories and waging unremitting war on the Confederacy were frightened by a man who really meant to achieve something.  The same is true of LA’s current and soon-to-be leaders; they talk about reform and real change, but recoil from the hard work of implementing a new perspective.  Unfortunately, we are facing a future of more rhetoric and little action, and the 74,000 unhoused people on our streets have little hope of meaningful help.

(Tim Campbell is a longtime Westchester resident and veteran public servant who spent his career managing a municipal performance audit program. Drawing on decades of experience in government accountability, he brings a results-driven approach to civic oversight. In his iAUDIT! column for CityWatchLA, Campbell emphasizes outcomes over bureaucratic process, offering readers clear-eyed analyses of how local programs perform—and where they fall short. His work advocates for greater transparency, efficiency, and effectiveness in Los Angeles government.)

Get The News In Your Email Inbox Mondays & Thursdays


Featured CityWatch Stories

HOUSING IS A HUMAN RIGHT - Nithya Raman will soon be the next mayor of Los Angeles, taking her oath of office in mid-De…
GELFAND'S WORLD - It’s a week later, give or take a couple of days, and miracles have happened. The election of Scott C…
DEMONSTRATIONS - Students rallied in Los Angeles and Huntington Park and called on LAUSD to fund support centers on eve…
THE BOTTOM LINE - As Los Angeles faces mounting financial pressures, the mayor-elect must explain why a multibillion-do…
THE BOTTOM LINE - Los Angeles taxpayers deserve answers, not another ribbon-cutting ceremony. After years of homelessne…