Skip to main content

When Red Tape is Really, Really Necessary

November 19 2026
Written by Bob Gelfand.

GELFAND’S WORLD - A few days ago, the U.S. government told all the major airports to forbid planes from taking off. It’s called a Ground Stop, and it got a lot of attention from television all over the country. Stranded travelers were interviewed about their plans and their misery. What nobody really answered was the simple question, “Why did this happen?”

We eventually got a semblance of an answer, which involved the claim that an electronic device known as a router had been replaced in Arkansas, and the new device immediately started sending a blast of signals that disabled communications all over the country.

We therefore had a mechanistic explanation -- partial and highly superficial – but we didn’t have the deeper explanation regarding the organizational weaknesses and errors that explained the deeper causes.

We now have the beginnings of that deeper explanation, which you can read in a CNN piece by Rene Marsh here. Boiled down to its essence, the CNN piece suggests that the problem was the lack of red tape. Yes, a lack of bureaucratic interference resulted in potential danger to aviation and the stranding of tens of thousands of travelers.

I use the term “red tape” advisedly. I refer to the sorts of organizational safeguards that are designed to check each part of the plan carefully and, beyond that, check that the overall design is not fatally flawed.

We might usefully begin with a counter-example. The first Space Shuttle crash occurred because the system was not designed to work in sub-freezing temperatures. In a previous disaster, three astronauts died in an Apollo capsule because a poorly designed exit hatch could not be opened during a fire. In each case, there was a lengthy investigation that led to changes in process and at least in one case led to a complete redesign.

These NASA disasters shocked the public, but illustrate a limited set of worst-case scenarios that occurred in systems that eventually were, in fact, full of bureaucratic red tape – the sorts of procedures that were designed to catch errors in highly experimental systems which were inherently dangerous. Had the American space exploration system been even a little bit less careful, there could have been many more such disasters. By creating a system of bureaucratic checks, NASA prevented a lot of potential disasters. The disasters that don’t happen are ignored by the public, but are recognized by the professionals who have to build the next space plane or moon lander.

Commercial aviation is not supposed to be experimental or inherently dangerous. When it is done properly, it turns out to be among the safest methods of transportation we have. But that is due to the careful work by the NTSB, the FAA, and thousands of engineers and aircraft manufacturers who have put in the hours (and dollars) necessary to develop the current level of safety.

It is therefore shocking to discover that the FAA – the organization that is responsible for ensuring airline safety – has intentionally fallen down on the job. How do we know this? If you read through the above linked article carefully, you will find that the FAA backed off on the sorts of controls and regulations that have traditionally been considered appropriate in any highly technical undertaking, particularly of the sort that involves direct danger to the public.

Let’s start with a brief view of the system. There are lots of airports that serve commercial aircraft within the continental United States. You can get a sense of the complexity simply by looking here at the aircraft in flight at any given time. Another way to look at it is that there are hundreds of airports, and an airplane could theoretically leave any of those airports and fly to any other of those airports. On any given day, a major airport such as LAX will be sending a large number of planes to the New York City area, to Chicago, to Philadelphia, and so on.

The air traffic control system has to keep track of those planes at all times in order to direct them as to direction, speed, and altitude. In addition, an aircraft which suffers some mechanical disability requires special handling by air traffic control.

And guess what? The FAA and the airports themselves have been complaining for years that their equipment is getting old and needs upgrades.

This is exactly the sort of situation which requires the ultimate level of care. If you are going to make changes to the equipment, you need to be sure that you aren’t going to screw anything up in the process. And that is exactly what this FAA did not do.

We have the basic elements of the story in the above cited CNN article. The current situation, if the report is even partly accurate, is that a contractor which should have been under the direct control of qualified FAA staff was allowed to replace an electronic part and its associated wiring all by itself and on its own say-so. And that, by the way, might not be the proximate cause of the near-disaster. What actually went on is much worse. What we now have, as the CNN article shows, is a new policy which drops bureaucratic regulation – what I referred to above as “red tape” – in order to cut costs marginally. The new policy as described above is consistent with everything else we heard about the actions of Elon Musk and his Doge organization during the early months of this second Trump administration.

If this is the wrong way to do engineering changes, what is the right way?

There is a proper approach.

So here is what you are supposed to do when you are engaging in a change that would be beneficial but could potentially result in a serious problem.

The first element of correct behavior is to think about the issue from the top down. In other words, you recognize that changing part of your internet structure could reverberate through a system which contains hundreds of airports serving thousands of daily flights. You ask yourself a couple of questions:

What do we need to accomplish?

What could go wrong?

Let me offer one more bit of terminology provided to me by a knowledgable friend: the Subject Matter Expert (SME).

It’s not a difficult concept. If you have a benign meningioma, you can be cured, but you need a brain surgeon. If you have a broken pipe in your bathroom, you need a plumber. Each is a subject matter expert.

In almost every endeavor that involves complicated technology (building cars, running a system of airports, studying the biology of the cell) there are many subjects (how to build and repair a runway, how to design an automatic transmission, what the endoplasmic reticulum does) and therefore lots of different subject matter experts.

In the case in question – the Ground Stoppage we just witnessed – there are experts in how the internet operates, the design and installation of internet routers, and people who are competent in the more esoteric aspects such as the ability of a misfiring router to mess up an entire system.

Obviously the process that just messed up the whole aviation system did not enjoy the benefits of these kinds of subject matter expertise.

The proper procedure is to start from a top-down perspective: Consider the entire air-traffic control system and how it interacts with its internet components. Think about what might go wrong if the one new component and its associated wiring are at all different from what is there now. We can infer that somebody goofed by omitting this step. Either that or the step was done haphazardly.

If you get as far as doing the top-down step competently, you assign the more definitive steps to subject matter experts. There are lots of experts on router design and operation.

The problem with doing things this way is that expenses pile up, and that goes against the attitude of the current administration. The Elon Musk group were determined to cut the number of employees, but the evidence suggests that they didn’t think too carefully about which employees or what would be lost by losing them.

May I suggest that the Ground Stoppage that we just observed was due to an attitude problem. Had the FAA and its contractors maintained the proper level of professionalism, the problem would not have occurred. A competent evaluation of the requested change would have found that there was some risk in putting the new device and its associated wiring into the old system and would, at the least, have resulted in some computer modeling of what might happen.

And by the way (as another example), there is a long history of unexpected effects that happen when you replace an old PC computer with a newer, faster model and try to run an old video game. And it’s not just games – almost any sufficiently complex piece of software can be thrown off the track when you (naively and inadvertently) change something that shouldn’t break something else, but does.

And deep down, there is another problem that most of us have noticed. The current president does not seem to appoint his top officials based on talent and competence. The current Secretary of Transportation comes across as a political appointee who lacks technical education but is slavishly attached to this administration’s ideology. It is an unhealthy mix.

At the very least, we should demand that mission-critical procedures that are overseen by government agencies are protected through the simple method of appointing smart, competent practitioners to head those agencies.

 

(Bob Gelfand writes on science, culture, and politics for CityWatch. He can be reached at [email protected])

Get The News In Your Email Inbox Mondays & Thursdays


Featured CityWatch Stories

DEMONSTRATIONS - Students rallied in Los Angeles and Huntington Park and called on LAUSD to fund support centers on eve…
THE BOTTOM LINE - Los Angeles taxpayers deserve answers, not another ribbon-cutting ceremony. After years of homelessne…
LA GOVERNMENT - When Hydee Feldstein Soto eliminated the Neighborhood Prosecutor Program, she dismantled one of the mor…
TRANSPORTATION - Eagle Rock residents want government that works. We want to get to school, work, and the grocery store…
IN NICK’S VIEW - Mayor-elect Nithya Raman has named transportation, the airport, and city department reform as early pr…